Do You Really Need 20 Percent Down?
No. You do not need 20 percent down to buy a house, and in El Paso you almost never should wait for it. Conventional loans start at 3 percent down, Federal Housing Administration loans at 3.5 percent, and Department of Veterans Affairs loans at zero. Millions of homes are bought every year with less than 20 percent down.
This is the most persistent myth in home buying, and it is expensive. Not because 20 percent is a bad idea in itself, but because waiting to save it usually costs more than the mortgage insurance you were trying to avoid. Below is the arithmetic on a $250,000 El Paso home, which is roughly our median, so you can see exactly where the money goes in each version.
Where the 20 Percent Idea Came From
It is not made up. Twenty percent is the threshold at which a conventional lender stops requiring private mortgage insurance, because at 80 percent loan to value the lender's risk drops enough that they will carry it themselves. That is a real line in real underwriting.
What happened is that a technical threshold turned into a moral one. Somewhere along the way, "20 percent is when insurance goes away" became "20 percent is what a responsible person puts down," and those are very different statements. The first is a fact about pricing. The second is advice that has kept a lot of qualified buyers renting for years.
The Arithmetic on a $250,000 El Paso Home
Twenty percent of $250,000 is $50,000. Five percent is $12,500. Ten percent is $25,000.
Here is what the monthly payment looks like at each, using a rate near 6.5 percent, a 30 year term, El Paso property taxes at roughly $520 a month escrowed, and homeowners insurance around $125 a month. Mortgage insurance figures are ranges, because the actual rate depends on your credit score and the insurer.
Five percent down, $237,500 financed
- Principal and interest: about $1,500
- Private mortgage insurance: roughly $100 to $170
- Taxes and insurance: about $645
- Total: roughly $2,245 to $2,315
Ten percent down, $225,000 financed
- Principal and interest: about $1,422
- Private mortgage insurance: roughly $60 to $115
- Taxes and insurance: about $645
- Total: roughly $2,127 to $2,182
Twenty percent down, $200,000 financed
- Principal and interest: about $1,264
- Private mortgage insurance: none
- Taxes and insurance: about $645
- Total: about $1,909
So the full gap between putting 5 percent down and 20 percent down is somewhere around $340 to $410 a month. Notice how much of that gap is not insurance at all. Most of it is simply financing $37,500 less. The mortgage insurance portion, the thing everyone is afraid of, is the smaller half.
Notice something else: taxes and insurance are identical in all three columns. A larger down payment does nothing to your escrow. In a state like Texas, where the tax line is the biggest surprise for out of state buyers, that matters. If you want the down payment options broken out in more detail, what you actually need down on a $250,000 El Paso house goes through them program by program.
What Private Mortgage Insurance Actually Costs and When It Stops
Private mortgage insurance on a conventional loan typically runs in a range of roughly 0.3 to 1.1 percent of the loan amount per year, and where you land inside that range is driven mostly by your credit score and your down payment size. Better score, bigger down payment, lower rate. It is added to your monthly payment and it is not permanent.
On a conventional loan you can request cancellation once you reach 80 percent loan to value, and the servicer must drop it automatically at 78 percent based on the original amortization schedule. On scheduled payments alone from a 5 percent down start, that is roughly a decade out. But most people get there much faster, because cancellation can also be based on current market value once enough time has passed, which means appreciation counts. Many servicers will consider a new appraisal after a couple of years of on time payments. Ask your lender at closing what their specific rules are, then set a calendar reminder.
Two important distinctions:
Federal Housing Administration loans work differently. Their mortgage insurance premium lasts the life of the loan when you put less than 10 percent down. At 10 percent or more it drops off after 11 years. Many buyers who start with a Federal Housing Administration loan refinance into a conventional loan later to shed it. That is a normal, planned move, not a failure.
Department of Veterans Affairs loans have no monthly mortgage insurance at all. Zero down, no monthly insurance, just a one time funding fee that is reduced for first use and waived entirely with a service connected disability rating. If you are eligible, the 20 percent conversation does not apply to you. The loan comparison guide lays the three programs side by side, and the Federal Housing Administration and Veterans Affairs loan page covers the El Paso specifics.
How Long It Takes to Save the Difference
This is the part that decides it.
Going from 5 percent to 20 percent on a $250,000 home means saving an additional $37,500. Not $50,000 total, just the difference, and only if the price stays where it is.
- Saving $500 a month: 75 months, a little over six years
- Saving $800 a month: about 47 months, just under four years
- Saving $1,200 a month: about 31 months, a bit over two and a half years
And most people cannot save $1,200 a month while renting. If they could, they would already be close.
Now compare that to what you were avoiding. At the middle of the range, mortgage insurance at 5 percent down on this house is about $135 a month. Four years of it is roughly $6,500, and in practice you would likely cancel it before then. You spent four years to avoid a cost that would have run you a few thousand dollars.
What Rent Costs You During the Wait
Use your own rent number here, not mine, because this is the line that does the real damage.
If your rent is $1,300 a month and you wait four years, you have paid $62,400 to a landlord. Every dollar of it is gone. Meanwhile the buyer who purchased four years ago has been paying down principal every month and has whatever the home gained in value on top of that.
I am not going to give you an appreciation forecast, because nobody honest has one. But you do not need appreciation for this to work. Even in a completely flat market, the principal portion of your payment is savings you are forced to make, and the tax deduction on mortgage interest is real for buyers who itemize. Flat is the pessimistic case, and flat still beats writing a rent check.
The honest counterweight is that owning carries costs renting does not: repairs, maintenance, and an escrow that rises when the county reassesses. That is a real argument, and I walk both sides in renting versus buying in El Paso. But it is an argument about whether to buy at all, not an argument for buying four years later with a bigger down payment.
When 20 Percent Down Genuinely Is the Right Move
I am not against it. Here is when I would actually do it.
You already have the money and reserves left over. If you can put $50,000 down and still have three to six months of expenses in the bank plus something for immediate repairs, do it. The lower payment is real and permanent.
You are stretching on the payment. If the difference between $1,909 and $2,280 a month is the difference between comfortable and tight, buy down the payment rather than buying up the price.
You are self employed or your income varies. A lower fixed obligation is worth a lot when your income has slow months.
What I would not do is put down every dollar you have. I have watched buyers close with $50,000 down and $800 in savings, and then the air conditioning unit fails in July, which in El Paso is not an inconvenience, it is an emergency. A 10 percent down payment with a real cushion behind it is a stronger financial position than 20 percent down and nothing.
One underrated detail on that middle ground: seller concession caps step up with your down payment on conventional loans. Under 10 percent down, a seller can contribute up to 3 percent toward your closing costs. At 10 to 25 percent down, that cap rises to 6 percent. On a $250,000 purchase, moving from 5 percent to 10 percent down can unlock several thousand additional dollars of seller paid closing costs, which partially funds the larger down payment. Ask your lender to model both.
If the Down Payment Is the Real Obstacle
There is help, and El Paso buyers underuse it. Down payment assistance programs, grant programs, and lender credits all exist here, most with income limits and a homebuyer education requirement, and most requiring you to start early rather than a week before closing. Start with the down payment assistance guide.
If you are close but not there, look at the lowest entry points before you look at waiting. Buying with 3 percent down covers the conventional low down payment programs, and buying with no money down in El Paso covers the zero down paths for those who qualify.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you need 20 percent down to buy a house?
No. Conventional loans go as low as 3 percent down, Federal Housing Administration loans 3.5 percent, and Department of Veterans Affairs loans zero. Twenty percent is only the point where private mortgage insurance is no longer required on a conventional loan.
How much is private mortgage insurance per month?
It generally runs in a range of about 0.3 to 1.1 percent of the loan amount per year, depending on your credit score and down payment. On a $237,500 loan that works out to roughly $100 to $170 a month, and it is removable rather than permanent.
Can I get rid of mortgage insurance later?
On a conventional loan, yes. You can request cancellation at 80 percent loan to value and it terminates automatically at 78 percent. Federal Housing Administration mortgage insurance lasts the life of the loan when you put down less than 10 percent, so refinancing later is the usual path off it.
Is it better to put 5 percent or 10 percent down?
Ten percent lowers the payment, lowers the mortgage insurance rate, and raises the seller concession cap from 3 percent to 6 percent on a conventional loan. If reaching 10 percent does not empty your savings, it is usually the better of the two. If it does, take 5 percent and keep the cushion.
Will a bigger down payment lower my property taxes?
No. Property taxes are based on the assessed value of the home, not on your loan, so the escrow portion of your payment is the same at any down payment. In El Paso that escrow is often $520 to $625 a month on a $250,000 home, which is why the total payment surprises out of state buyers.
Do veterans need a down payment in Texas?
No. Department of Veterans Affairs loans allow zero down within your entitlement, with no monthly mortgage insurance and a one time funding fee that is waived for borrowers with a service connected disability rating.
The Bottom Line
Twenty percent down is a discount, not a requirement. If you have it and you still have savings behind it, take the lower payment and enjoy it. If you do not have it, the choice is not between 20 percent down and 5 percent down. It is between buying now at 5 percent down and buying in four years, after paying tens of thousands of dollars in rent, in order to avoid a cost of roughly $135 a month that you were going to cancel anyway.
That is the trade, stated plainly. Most El Paso buyers should not take it. If you want to see the real numbers on your own situation, both versions side by side with current El Paso tax rates rather than a national average, reach out and I will run them with you before you decide anything.